Saturday, February 10, 2007

I have recently acquired a turntable--this has been one of the happiest things. I am a lover of music, and like anyone born after 1980, by the time I was allowed to purchase music, we advanced from the archaic vinyl disc and "moved on" to tape. Further, by the time I "got into" music, tape was usurped by the more "compact" plastic disc, only with a laser instead of a needle. Now, Apple has fooled us into thinking music is a bunch of 1's and 0's -- and thus to listen to music in our current age is to listen to a computer signal.

Well, let me tell you what a joy it is to pull out a clumsy plastic disc, lay it upon a perfect circle, lift the needle and lay it gently upon the outer fringes of the disc.

So I have been internally compiling reasons I think listening to records is better than listening to cd's/mp3's. I decided to make the list here. So here it goes.

1. Album art - quite nonexistent with digital music (and the little box on the video iPod hardly counts!)
2. Records sound better - there is something more immediate, full, and spacious about vinyl. It is simply a false lie that digital music is "cleaner" and better quality. No, friends, digital music is flat.
3. Experience - Listening to a record requires time. It slows you down--it forces involvement on the behalf of the listener. It requires so much attention, the music is never relegated to "background music," a place I think music was never intended to go. (think about music lovers who feel awkward just sitting around a computer listening to music--we were meant to just listen to music; the digital music phase simply makes this awkward.)
4. Imperfection - this does not run counter to reason #2. In our digital world, we have falsely assumed that music must be overproduced, clean, and "flawless." It is is a false assumption. We live in a fallen world, where beauty and ruin exist side by side. To create art, and thus view/listen to art that doesn't account for this reality is shallow and deceptive. Why do you think people like Ryan Adams/Johnny Cash over Jimmy Eat World? Records have imperfections, thats all I'm saying.
5. Time - You can actually watch the music play as the needle moves down the groove closer to the center of the disc. This is far better and realistic than a digital time-piece telling you the "track" and "time" of the song.
6. There is no such thing as digital - Dr. Pratt helped me understand that even "digital" signals are analog -- just really really fast analog. We live in an analog world, nothing in life is "1"or "0". Our lived reality is not that clean, hard, and fast. Dare I say digital is hurried, compressed, and worse sounding analog.
7. You can't steal from a musician - It's quite easy to steal a musician's lunch by not buying their art, but making a copy in a digital world. This is impossible and undesirable in a vinyl world.
8. Bigger is better - We want to make everything smaller-who says that is a virtue?
9. Community - You can't carry your turntable with you everywhere earphones in tact, and thus pretend the shared world around you doesn't exist. Instead, with vinyl, everyone hears the music--and very often you simply invite others over to listen to records (they even make backpacks to carry records).
10. The record store - support your local record shop. Enough said. I know capitalism does what it does, but it pains me to see these local shops die because of a website with digital storehouse of music.

6 Comments:

Blogger Michael H said...

i love that you're using sin and the human condition as a justification for vinyl over digital. well done, my friend.

11:37 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Joe,

Good little treatise on the appeal of the record player.

Can you get alot of new releases on vinyl? Or are you skimming the older shops for even older records? Forgive my lack of urban hipster knowledge here, but how hard is it to find newer stuff?

Donahoe

1:56 AM  
Blogger Joe and Josie Haack said...

most musicians release their stuff on vinyl still! the biggest irony in this whole ordeal is that I am repurchasing albums I already own in cd format to vinyl...Just my favorite produced one's anyway. (Lanois, Wilco, etc.)

1:59 PM  
Blogger Heather said...

dude, can I have your ipod.

7:57 PM  
Blogger rustafarian said...

haack, glad you're spinning the vinyl. did you buy shine by lanois? i own that on vinyl, but i no longer have a working record player. suck!

3:52 PM  
Blogger Joe and Josie Haack said...

yeah, I bought shine, which sounds so great on vinyl...it is amazing. I remember the days that you used to spin Live at Leeds at the Camp.

haack

7:09 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home